How can relief be provided to the absconders when they have no trust on system: CJ IHC

0

Chief Justice (CJ) Islamabad High Court (IHC) Athar Minallah has remarked how can the relief be given to the absconders when they have no trust on system.

He further remarked there can be no separate law for the absconders. The court has already made it clear in Musharraf case. How can the speech of the absconders be allowed to be broadcast at TV.PEMRA has imposed ban on broadcasting speech at TV but no ban is in place on publishing the news item on this count.

Petition filed against imposition of ban on broadcasting Nawaz Sharif and former federal minister Ishaq Dar speeches on TV came up for hearing before CJ IHC Thursday.

The court while giving time to the counsel of petitioners for making further preparations in the case adjourned the hearing of the case.

Suleman Akram Raja appeared on behalf of the petitioners who are journalists .

The CJ IHC inquired for whom you are seeking relief.

The lawyer said “we are seeking relief in public interest.

CJ IHC remarked “ this court made it clear in Pervez Musharraf case this court does not interfere in any executive matter. The people have lost their confidence on judiciary due to political problems. Parveiz Musharraf was also absconder. In this case we have said this petitioner wants what that to whom permission be given. PEMRA issued order. Under section 31, appeal can be filed before PEMRA. Who filed appeal before PEMRA. Who was affected by this. What law is for common man will be for all people in this court. If someone has not filed appeal it means no one was affected by this order. There are two names here who are court absconders. Have these two persons been affected or media channel has been affected. They should file appeal before PEMRA who have been affected.

Counsel for petitioner Suleman Akram Raja said not only two but thousands of people are absconding. The petitioners want that they should not be barred from providing information to the people. The petitioners have been affected.

The CJ IHC remarked “ everyone enjoys freedom of expression as per article 19 of the constitution. The citizenship and identity card of absconding person are blocked. How the petitioner have been affected. Do you want Pervez Musharraf speech be broadcast. Do the petitioners want that court’s absconders speeches be broadcast at TV. When a person has been declared proclaimed offender and the national identity card of court’s absconder has been blocked then do you want that there should be separate law for the absconder. Do the petitioners want Pervez Musharraf delivers speech on TV. No one among the petitioners has been affected. The court’s absconder has not resorted to this court. Then how can you. PEMRA order has barred from broadcasting the speech of court’s absconder. But it has not prevented from broadcasting news item in this respect.

He further observed “ being absconder is a serious issue. The absconding culprits are discussed daily. Only they have been prevented from being given air time. Satisfy the court the absconder can get relief only if he appears in the court. Do you want to do it for all the absconders? Whosoever is absconder will resort to court on his own when he is affected. Government released the absconder and placed blame on this court.

The counsel for the petitioner said PEMRA order is meant for the journalists and the media persons therefore, they are affected party. I will inform the court after discussing it with my clients.
The CJ IHC remarked expression of freedom and rights to information are basic right of every one. Law is in place in the entire world for the absconders. This court cannot provide relief indirectly to any absconder. There are thousands of absconders here. How can we give them relief if they have no trust on judicial system. This is test of judicial system. You want these all absconding accused be given relief. Giving relief to any absconder is not in the public interest. Expression of freedom is must. But here the question is some what different.

Counsel for PEMRA said PEMRA has no powers and these powers rest with parliament.

CJP IHC remarked no proclaimed offender can challenge any illegal order. Pervez Musharraf was absconder who had no trust on this judicial system and the court.

The court while giving time to lawyer Suleman Akram Raja for preparations in connection with the case adjourned the hearing of the case till December 16.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.